wild places | wild happenings | wild news
make a difference for our wild places

home | links | search the site
  all articles latest | past | articles by topics | search wildnews
wild news on wildsingapore
  BBC 8 Dec 05
Row over wild birds' flu role

PlanetArk 9 Dec 05
Role of Wild Birds in Avian Flu Spread Questioned
Story by Ed Stoddard

JOHANNESBURG - A conservation group said on Thursday there was little evidence to back the view that migrating wildfowl were spreading bird flu and said that eastern Europe's outbreak probably stemmed from poultry imports.

"As the year draws to a close, millions of wild birds have flown to their wintering sites across Asia, Africa, Europe and the Americas without the widely predicted outbreaks of H5N1 bird flu associated with their migration routes," BirdLife International said in a statement.

"The most obvious explanation is that migrating wild birds are not spreading the disease," said Dr Michael Rands, Director and Chief Executive of BirdLife.

However, animal health experts said they could not rule out the involvement of wild birds in spreading the virus across Asia and into eastern Europe.

"It is now not possible to exclude the role of some aquatic wild birds in the transmission of the current Asian strain H5N1 to domestic birds close to the migratory routes of these wild birds," Bernard Vallat, Director General of the World Organisation for Animal Health (OIE), told Reuters.

The H5N1 bird flu virus has killed nearly 70 people in five Asian countries since 2003 leading to mass culls of birds.

NO "SMOKING GUN"

Officials say the H5N1 virus could spread to new countries through migratory birds from China, Mongolia, Vietnam and Russia - which have reported major outbreaks. The US-based Wildlife Conservation Society earlier this year helped confirm that swans and other birds carried avian flu to a lake in Mongolia.

But BirdLife said no "smoking gun" had been detected among migratory wild birds in eastern Europe.

"The limited outbreaks in eastern Europe are on southerly migration routes but are more likely to be caused by other vectors such as the import of poultry or poultry products. The hypothesis that wild birds are to blame is simply far from proven," said Rands.

"Wild birds occasionally come into contact with infected poultry and die: they are the victims not vectors of H5N1 bird flu," he said.

The OIE's Vallat agreed that trade in birds could also play a role in the spread of bird flu. "...the potential transmission of the virus through commercial and non commercial exchanges of live domestic birds including pets and products may also play an important role," he added.

Vallat did not want to see a mass cull of wild birds. "The destruction of wild birds to avoid transmission to domestic birds is strongly not recommended because, among other things, it would lead to the dispersion of birds and would facilitate the spread of the virus worldwide," Vallat added.

BirdLife said banning the movement of poultry and related products from infected areas and restricting the global trade in captive birds were the best prevention methods.

The H5N1 strain has not been detected in Africa yet but experts say uncovering it in the region's rural areas will be difficult because of poor logistics and already high mortality rates among the continent's backyard chickens. (Additional reporting by David Evans in Paris)

BBC 8 Dec 05
Row over wild birds' flu role

There is little evidence to suggest migrating birds are spreading avian flu, a conservation group has said.

BirdLife International said that even though winter migration was well under way across the world, there had not been widespread bird flu outbreaks.

But the UN's top bird flu expert said he was "furious" about the statement, saying it was too early to judge.

Concerns about wild birds were sparked by the death earlier this year of 5,000 migratory birds in north-west China.

"Migratory wild birds were blamed for spreading bird flu west from Asia, yet there's been no spread back eastwards, nor to South Asia and Africa this autumn," Dr Michael Rands, director and chief executive of BirdLife International said in a statement.

Dr Rands acknowledged the recent outbreaks in eastern Europe were on southern migratory routes, but said it was more likely they were caused by other factors, such as importing fowl.

"The hypothesis that wild birds are to blame is simply far from proven," said Dr Rands. "Wild birds occasionally come into contact with infected poultry and die: they are the victims not vectors of H5N1 bird flu."

But Dr Joseph Domenech, chief veterinary officer at the UN's Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO), said it was too early to dismiss the theory that wild birds could be spreading the disease.

He said that there were "quite good indications" that the disease had arrived in a series of countries, including Romania, as a result of wildlife.

'Wait and see'

He stressed that the FAO had always said that there needed to be more study of this, but at this stage it was too early to dismiss the hypothesis. He also said outbreaks in certain regions were harder to monitor as the countries involved had poorer surveillance.

"If at the end of the [migratory] season, birds are going back to the Northern countries and no outbreaks have been identified, then we will be able to say the hypothesis... may be not true," he said, adding that such return journeys would begin at the beginning of February.

Dr Rands said in his statement that better "biosecurity" - concentrating on the risks involved in the trade of poultry and caged birds - was the key to halting the spread of bird flu.

Dr Domenech said that the FAO agreed that this was the most important area to concentrate on.

Fears about the H5N1 virus have led to the slaughter of millions of chickens and ducks across Asia in the last 18 months. The UN is alarmed that the more the virus spreads, the greater the chances it could mutate into a form capable of causing a flu pandemic.
links
Related articles on Global issues: Bird Flu
about the site | email ria
  News articles are reproduced for non-profit educational purposes.
 

website©ria tan 2003 www.wildsingapore.com